My Positions (Thanks, Sabio)
April 12, 2012 8 Comments
A handy-dandy chart (courtesy of Sabio at Triangulations) of my atheist positions:
Self-Label(s) | Atheist about most gods, agnostic about a rare few |
Past Sect History | None – god wasn’t even a consideration in my home |
Past Belief History | Life Long Non-believer (Natural) |
Past Orthopraxy History | Not much, some meditation now and again |
Level of Certainty: | Moderate (see “Self-Label(s)) |
Openness: | Open, but cautious – I find it irrelevant in most contexts, but I neither want to cause offence nor become a target for conversion |
Degree of Outreach: | Affirm my atheism, but willing to go more in-depth with those who want to know (not exactly ‘debates’ though) |
Present Religious Participation: | If meditation in my home counts, fairly frequently – but hardly ever in a group context (>1/yr.) |
Stance toward Categorically Rejecting Religion: | Friendly. I think religions are good or bad based on their particularities, but nothing is bad about the phenomenon, per se. It is what it is. |
Degree of Enchantment | Over-awed, both by the beautiful and the terrible. |
Mystical Perceptions: | Partially Mystical |
Theory of Religion: | succinctly, I think religions arise as a side effect of other features of human psychology – there is no god gene. |
Non-theistic Leanings | I think the universe is much more mysterious than we give it credit, usually. I have days where I lean panendeist, but I have no strong commitment to the idea. I’m still trying to sort this out myself. |
Secular Superstitious or Irrational Habits | I play scratch-and-wins. Sometimes I win $2! Other than that, only when I’m flying. |
View of Reason | Reason is really important, it’s the best we can do. Unlike many, however, I have a pretty dim view of how reasonable we really are. I’m a reluctant Humean on this point. |
Faith Items | Mmm, that consciousness might extend much further and deeper in the world than we imagine. That there is no real indeterminacy in the universe. |
And another of my philosophical positions:
School of Philosophy: | Analytic |
Ontology: | Naturalist (although I have problems with the term). |
Science: | Scientific realism (tentative) |
Theory of Time: | B-Theory |
Theology: | Atheist (mostly) and agnostic regarding a handful of other positions, but friendly towards an idiosyncratic panendeism. |
Politics: | Libertarianism, leavened with the faintest whiff of egalitarianism |
Language: | Russellianism by default, don’t know enough about Frege to intelligently commit. |
Mind: | Physicalist with the potential exception of consciousness itself. |
Mental Content: | Externalism |
Abstract Objects: | Nominalism |
Knowledge: | Empiricism / Rationalism (Both – I don’t think either can be separated from the other) |
Personal Identity: | Psychological-Causal History |
Free Will: | Agnostic on the compatibilism/incompatibilism divide. I think much more important that whether we strictly have free will is whether moral responsibility can be salvaged. Although I feel like compatibilist schemes rescue MR better. |
Normative Ethics: | Virtue Ethics with a good splash of deontology (for tough cases) |
Meta-Ethics: | I think it’s safe to say I’m a non-cognitivist of a sort. Again, I haven’t worked out in too much detail my schema of meta-ethics (for lack of time and being to fixated on day-to-day ethics). |
No immortal soul?
No, I don’t think so. Or it would surprise me if there was, let’s just say that.
Interesting. It’s always been my view that taking away the immortal soul opens quite a can of moral worms. If death is really all she wrote, I don’t see why any rational person would choose to be moral. I, for one, would live like a rockstar.
Yeah, that’s a common worry (although usually its articulated as “if no god, why be moral”). Actually, this is an interesting topic and it has given me motivation to write a post about, so I will do that if you can be patient! 🙂
Indeed! I’ll do my best.
Very nice !
(1) You ought to put a link in so others can find it and do the same.
(2) Now put a link in your side bar to this post “What I believe”
I agree with you completely and those will be up very soon! Credit where it’s due, my man!
SMILE